help me. again.

oh no... well, cos NYU students get random special discounts and stuff. So before i came here, i decided that i'll watch Phantom of the Opera on Sept 14, cos theyre offering a HUMONGOUS discount. then just now i checked the lineup again, and RENT was on too -- same time, same date. So now I have no idea which one to go for. Roughly the same price -- phantom is 34usd for NYU peeps, Rent is 33. HELPPP!!! TAG OR SUMTHINN!!! Phantom cos its classic and drama/emo? or Rent cos its New York City for crying out loud?!? i love them both equally! help help help!!!